Members of ApeCoin DAO (decentralized autonomous organization), have voted to stay on Ethereum, instead of moving to another layer 1 or layer 2 blockchain.
The vote passed by a small margin as 53.62% voted to stay on Ethereum, with 46.38% against the proposal.
— ApeCoin (@apecoin) June 9, 2022
Only 7.1 million ApeCoin (APE) were used in the voting process, or less than 3% of the total circulating supply of over 292 million. However, a few members yielded maximum influence within this week-long voting process.
For instance, a DAO member who goes by the pseudonym ‘Machi Big Brother‘ on Twitter, used 1.2 million APE to vote against the proposal. His vote represented around 17% of the total votes and over 36% of the votes against the proposal.
Following the approval of proposal AIP-41, no further proposals about moving ApeCoin to another blockchain can be made for the next three months.
What’s all the contention about?
‘AIP-41: Keep ApeCoin within the Ethereum ecosystem’ was proposed on May 2 after Yuga Labs, the creator of the Bored Apes ecosystem, hinted at the need to move to another blockchain to scale. Yuga Labs tweeted that the ApeCoin DAO needed to start thinking about moving away from Ethereum, which is plagued by gas fee woes.
We’re sorry for turning off the lights on Ethereum for a while. It seems abundantly clear that ApeCoin will need to migrate to its own chain in order to properly scale. We’d like to encourage the DAO to start thinking in this direction.
— Yuga Labs (@yugalabs) May 1, 2022
Yuga Labs’ comments came after it faced issues with the sale of land parcels of its yet-to-be-released Otherside metaverse. The Bored Apes Yacht Club creator blamed Ethereum for being unable to cope with demand.
So different blockchains started proposing a move to their network. Avalanche came first, proposing that not only should ApeCoin move to an Avalanche subnet, but even Otherside should be launched there as well. The proposal said:
“We propose that ApeCoin DAO launches Otherside on an Avalanche Subnet to support Otherside’s future community growth through rapid transaction processing, higher throughput, greater ability to scale and lower gas fees.”
NFTstartup Immutable, which runs the Immutable X network, submitted a similar proposal soon after.
Then came AIP-41, which said that ApeCoin should stay on Ethereum, which provides better security and liquidity. The argument against moving to another blockchain was that it would be “too complex and costly.” The proposal said:
“Migrating to a different chain is a costly, risky, and complex endeavor with many moving parts that may, if not thoughtfully considered, result in catastrophic loss, or at worst, abandonment by Yuga Labs.”
The community remains divided
While the majority voted for ApeCoin to stay put on Ethereum, the community is torn into a debate over whether it was the best decision.
Some community members have expressed concern that the three-month waiting period before another proposal can be made on the subject could impact demand for the token.
A community member, for instance, called the decision “short sighted.”
This AIP doesn’t make sense
Preemptively excluding an option for future growth with an arbitrary time limit seems short sighted at best
But it’s also contra to the DAO ethos: Building
We should spend time on growth/adoption
Not passing proposals where we agree to do nothing https://t.co/Xz6h6ZMuR0
— BradleyZastrow 🦇🔊 (@ZastrowBradley) June 9, 2022
Another member said the decision to stay on Ethereum could “completely destroy the value of APE.”
This is cryptocurrency, and pausing any decisions for 3 full months, PLUS the time to vote and actually take action, is anything but simple. This has the ability to completely destroy the value of APE. Imagine if ETH merge happens and completely shits the bed. Game over.
— Minty | Otherdeed #45427 (@mintycollector) June 6, 2022
At the same time, community members in favor of staying on Ethereum have hailed the decision as prudent. Some members commented on the proposal expressing that the gas fees problems may be resolved with the impending Ethereum Merge.
Even the ones who are in favor of moving to another chain are divided in their views. Some believe moving to a layer-2 solution would be better, while others suggest moving to a layer-1 blockchain.
ApeCoin is currently the 36th largest cryptocurrency with a market cap of nearly $1.7 billion. The token’s price is down 3.29 % in the past 24 hours, trading at around $5.79, over 70% lower than its all-time high of around $25.